Awhile ago I went to this conference which discussed the idea of
'structural racism'. It's a complex concept that describes how institutions and people's implicit beliefs maintain racism, thus preventing the targets of this racism to get ahead in life. However, I think it can be extended past the borders of racism to encompass basic value judgments on other people as well. It was an interesting talk, but it's always more fascinating to see it happen in real life...
The other day I was having a conversation with an American about healthcare which turned into her view that the Canadian system sucks because you have to wait to get access to healthcare. Now, while wait times certainly are a huge area of concern for our system, the issue wasn't necessarily the quality of healthcare. The issue was getting what you want when you want it because that's what you 'deserve':
- "Americans work hard for their money and they should get the healthcare they deserve"
- "If you don't have healthcare, just get a job"
- "My hard earned dollars shouldn't go toward paying for some lazy person's healthcare"I promptly pointed out that some people can't get jobs with good benefits, or obtain any sort of employment. The response:
- "The people who can't get employment are homeless and lazy"
- "Everyone has an equal opportunity to get a job in this country"
- "People who make a lot of money work hard and they deserve to keep their money"So I says to the chick, I says sure lazy people exist everywhere. But a lot of homeless people have mental illnesses that prevent them from maintaining a job. Further, in the American system, they can't afford to see a psychiatrist or pay for medication so they'll never get better. Other people have the misfortune of being disabled due to an accident or disease which prevents them not only from working, but from getting decent healthcare coverage even if they had the money to pay for it! And even if they are lazy, are they not people too? Are they not Americans? What about children of lazy people - should they be denied access to good healthcare?
As for people who make lots of money - ever heard of nepotism? How about
white privilege? If you are black in America and have a history of slavery in your family, do you really think that money has been passed down in the generations that could allow successive generations to pay for college and subsequently obtain a high paying job? Or do you think white people have a much better chance of doing so? Maybe the people who do the hiring at these jobs don't want to hire a black person because they think they're all lazy, or stupid, or they'd rather hire the boss's daughter who is a terribly inept employee but wears see-through clothes to work so the guys want her hanging around the water cooler.
These people still believe in the American Dream of working hard and achieving success, and are totally heartless when it comes to helping out other people, regardless of whether they are legitimately disadvantaged or not. I says to her, "don't you people say you're one nation under god, and all men were created equal?" Isn't that the shit you people say? She just laughed and said "that has never been true and never will be."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
ps: I don't want to sound all idealistic and hippie with this post. You people should know by now that I am irritated by pretty much everyone I come in contact with. But when I hear someone say all of that shit in one sitting, I realize how ridiculous it sounds. Yes, I would love to get access to doctors instantly and never have to wait for anything. But as someone who is perpetually broken and has bandaids and staples holding me together, I am well aware that if I were an American, I would be one of the poor, lazy, uninsured people who doesn't deserve healthcare because apparently I'm not willing to try hard enough.